Mafolie Hotel – Room Style

Rooms at Mafolie Hotel are boutique-style with balconies or terraces that showcase the property's signature harbor and hillside views in an intimate setting.

• Comfortable rooms with a personal, boutique feel
• Many rooms feature panoramic Charlotte Amalie views
• Ideal for travelers who want charm and scenery over sprawling space

Mafolie is the better pick if you want a cozy hillside retreat with memorable views and easy access to town.

Point Pleasant Resort – Room Style

Point Pleasant Resort offers suite-style accommodations with kitchen facilities, providing more space and self-catering options for longer stays or independent travelers.

• Larger suites with living areas and full or partial kitchens
• Spread across tropical hillside grounds with water views
• Best for travelers who want room to spread out and cook their own meals

If you want more square footage, kitchen convenience, and a condo-style feel, Point Pleasant is usually the stronger fit.

Mafolie Hotel – Pool & Amenities

Mafolie Hotel features a pool terrace with sweeping harbor views, offering a relaxed spot to unwind while taking in the Charlotte Amalie scenery.

• Pool terrace with panoramic harbor views
• Intimate setting with a boutique atmosphere
• Best for travelers who want views and relaxation over pool variety

Point Pleasant Resort – Pool & Amenities

Point Pleasant Resort spreads across tropical hillside grounds with multiple pool areas, offering more variety and a resort-style feel.

• Multiple pools spread throughout the property
• Lush tropical landscaping and hillside setting
• Better for travelers who want more pool options and grounds to explore

If you want more pool variety and a larger resort footprint, Point Pleasant delivers more amenity space.

Mafolie Hotel – Location

Mafolie Hotel's hillside location puts you close to Charlotte Amalie, making it convenient for shopping, dining, and catching ferries to nearby islands.

• Near Charlotte Amalie town and the ferry terminal
• Easy access to town amenities and excursions
• Not beachfront—guests drive to nearby St. Thomas beaches

Point Pleasant Resort – Location

Point Pleasant Resort sits on St. Thomas's quieter East End, offering a more secluded feel with proximity to popular beaches in that area.

• Located on the East End, away from town bustle
• Small beach cove on property; nearby beaches like Lindquist within reach
• Better for travelers who want seclusion and East End beach access

If you prefer a quieter location closer to St. Thomas's East End beaches, Point Pleasant offers more seclusion.

Mafolie Hotel – Value Snapshot

Mafolie Hotel offers the most value when you want harbor views, on-site dining, and a boutique atmosphere near Charlotte Amalie.

• Best for couples, solo travelers, and those who value views
• Great if you want convenient access to town and ferries
• Strong value for travelers who prioritize atmosphere and scenery

Point Pleasant Resort – Value Snapshot

Point Pleasant Resort is the better value if your priorities are suite space, kitchen facilities, and a quieter East End location.

• Best for longer stays, families, or self-catering travelers
• Stronger for guests who want more room and independence
• Worth it if you want a secluded tropical retreat with suite amenities